The Admiral and the Barkeep


Nelson’s Dockyard is the historical enclave  that was the home of Admiral Horatio Nelson’s royal navy in the 1700’s. The Antiguan government has gone to great lengths to repurpose the buildings for modern use, while preserving their heritage and history.  The admiral himself occupied a building that is now an upscale hotel known as the Admiral’s Inn, and after a hot day exploring the island we sauntered in to its cherry-wood beamed tavern for a late afternoon beverage. It was here that my perception of the cocktail was forever altered.

I am not much of an imbiber, but as an aspiring chef  I appreciate culinary artistry in any form, and in this case the artistry graced  mixology. As I sat at the bar awaiting attention from the bartender, I noticed him creating some of the most meticulously attended and beautifully crafted cocktails I had ever seen.
Reggie

I could not help but to offer commendation to this artist barkeep, and he, Reggie,   graciously responded in his Antiguan-English lilt. “The art of the cocktail” he instructed, “ is not just in combining contents, but in the manner in which they are presented”.  I inquired about one particularly lovely libation that he set on the bar. “A rum punch”, he announced, “ but made in the old fashioned manner”.  The rum punch  which I knew as  familiar fare in these   tropical climes was  artificially colored  imitation fruit juice mixed with cheap rum and a maraschino cherry. Not so under Reggie’s tutelage. His was a production, involving hand pressed lime and layered rums, topped with bitters and nutmeg. Not only was it a work of art, it was the most delicious cocktail I had ever experienced. “Layering rum is vital to the proper rum drink”, Reggie explained. “White is for power, dark is for flavor. Most people do not understand that white rum has higher alcohol content and gives the drink its punch. It is the quality of the dark rum that makes the drink flavorful, and as they have different viscosities, they should be layered so that the customer may enjoy the drink as it unfolds.”  He replicated this philosophy with another Caribbean classic, the  Dark and Stormy. “People pour rum into ginger ale and swirl it around like they are making chocolate milk. The proper Dark and Stormy is cascading sheets of ginger beer rain descending from the  storm clouds  of dark  rum. The drink must give homage to its name”. So it was that Reggie the barkeep at the Admiral’s Inn in Nelson’s Dockyard in English Harbor Antigua has entered the lore of my sailing life, assuming that after my second Old Fashioned, I remember any of it accurately.  
 
Old Fashioned Rum Punch and Dark and Stormy
Reggie's Old Fashioned Rum Punch recipe:
two teaspoons of simple syrup in bottom of manhattan glass
Wash Lime and rinse
Cut 1/2 of lime and hand squeeze gently enough to allow juice into glass, but not so much as to crush and misshapen the lime. Drop the lime into the syrup, cut end facing up
Add high quality white rum
Pour slowly and gently high quality dark rum into the side of the glass so that it does not glop into the white rum
Sprinkle 6 or 8 drops of Angostura Bitters
Sprinkle nutmeg